Call Now  (713) 227-4444 Email Us Hablamos
Español

Neal Davis Blog

  • About
    • Neal Davis
    • Tyler Brock
    • Andrew Jordan
    • Hiring An Attorney
  • Expertise
    • Criminal Defense
    • Sex Crime Defense
    • Child Pornography
    • Child Solicitation
    • Drug Possession
    • White Collar Crimes
    • Shoplifing/Theft
    • DWI
    • Murder Defense
    • Assault & Family Violence
    • Title IX Defense
  • Results
  • Reviews
  • Press
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • Criminal Defense Guides
    • Scholarships
Home / Criminal Defense / Mistaken Eyewitness Identifications Can be Followed by Exoneration and Freedom

Mistaken Eyewitness Identifications Can be Followed by Exoneration and Freedom

December 17, 2021

Anthony Broadwater exoneration

Did you know that more than two-thirds of the 375 wrongful convictions overturned in America by DNA evidence involved overcoming mistaken eyewitness identifications?

That finding came from the Innocence Project, a non-profit organization that champions such exonerations and the rights of people who were wrongly accused and convicted of crimes they did not commit.

Wrongful conviction of Broadwater is overturned

Another exoneration can be added to that total, thanks to the recent vacating of the conviction of Anthony Broadwater at the age of 61. After being wrongfully convicted of raping a woman in Syracuse, NY, in 1981, he served 16 years in state prison.

But it wasn’t DNA evidence that cleared Broadwater’s name, who’d struggled to survive financially after his release from prison for a crime he did not commit. (The DNA evidence in Broadwater’s trial was destroyed in 1989.)

Rather, a filmmaker who was working on a documentary film about the rape victim’s memoir suspected that Broadwater was innocent and then hired a private investigator to look into his case.

Less than 6 months later, on Nov. 22, 2021, Broadwater’s conviction was vacated in a New York court. There, the judge and prosecutor both agreed that the case against him had been deeply and profoundly flawed.

For one thing, the victim had identified another man as her assailant, instead of Broadwater, in a police lineup 6 months after the attack. However, prosecutors back then coached her into “rehabilitation” of her choice. They also presented as evidence a form of hair analysis, which has since been discredited as junk science.

In addition, Broadwater was the only Black man in the courtroom at his trial. As he told the Syracuse Post Standard:

“I didn’t realize that no matter what I did, I was probably going to be convicted.”

Broadwater, who had no prior criminal record and was honorably discharged from the U.S. Marines shortly before being accused, was released from prison in 1999. His release from a sentence of up to 25 years could have been sooner, but after 5 parole hearings over the years he refused to confess and show remorse for a crime he did not commit, which meant he stayed in prison.

Even after his release, Broadwater was listed as a registered violent sex offender, which made it extremely difficult for him to get jobs. He also felt as though he was ostracized by the world at large.

Since his exoneration, Broadwater has had his name excised from the registry of violent sex offenders. In addition, his accuser – who wrote a successful novel based on the rape and thus profited from it while he suffered – has apologized to him.

“No crime survivor wants an innocent person to go to prison,” Jennifer Thompson, founder of the Healing Justice Project, told the Washington Post. Her organization assists survivors, exonerated persons and their families in such cases.

“It’s egregious all the way around,” she said. “I’m so sad for everybody. There are no winners in these stories except for the perpetrator.”

Restitution, or payments, can be sought after exoneration

The Post reported that Broadwater’s defense attorneys also are seeking restitution from the state of New York. That means they will argue that the state should pay Broadwater for the years he spent in prison.

As our law firm has previously written, the Innocence Project recommends that exonerated persons be paid $50,000 for each year that they were wrongfully held in prison. The Project also advises that part of restitution should include paying all attorney fees from their trial.

Seek the best Houston-area criminal defense lawyer

If someone in your family has been wrongfully accused of a crime they did not commit, it’s vital you seek the best Houston criminal defense lawyer you can find to fight for your family’s legal rights.

The award-winning Neal Davis Law Firm has years of experience handling such cases. We’ve even conducted an extensive study of the state of wrongful convictions in America, and we stand ready to help those who do not deserve to be behind bars.

We also support reforms in the handling of eyewitness identifications, which, as has been shown, can lead to wrongful convictions.

Eyewitness identification reforms are needed

The Innocence Project has argued for many such reforms, including requiring an eyewitness to make a statement right after identifying someone in a police lineup—in their own words—about their level of confidence in that decision.

It also advises that the person who administers the lineup should have no idea who the suspect is, thereby avoiding any unjust influence or steering of the eyewitness.

The Project reports that 25 states – including Texas – have implemented its recommended core reforms, either via court action, legislation or substantial voluntary compliance.

If your loved one faces a wrongful accusation or charge of a felony or misdemeanor crime in Houston, The Woodlands, Conroe, Sugar Land or elsewhere in Harris County, Montgomery County or Fort Bend County, contact a veteran criminal defense lawyer today at the Neal Davis Law Firm.

Schedule a confidential consultation for your case, after which you can decide how you want to proceed.

Related Resources

  • How Much Money Can Bond Be?
    How Much Money Can Bond Be?
  • Teacher Arrests Rise for Inappropriate Contact With Students
    Teacher Arrests Rise for Inappropriate Contact With Students
  • Sentencing and Penalty Guidelines for White-Collar Crimes
    Sentencing and Penalty Guidelines for White-Collar Crimes

Learn More About Criminal Defense


Overview of Criminal Defense
Questions to Ask Your Attorney
White Collar Crime
Crime Classifications
Common Criminal Defense Questions
Have You Been Arrested
Death Penalty Law
Criminal Defense Legal Terms
Rights of the Defendant
Employment after Incarceration

Categories

  • Child Pornography & Online Solicitation
  • Community
  • Criminal Defense
  • Drug Crimes
  • Federal Crimes
  • Firm News
  • Intoxication Offenses
  • Sex Crimes
  • Violent Crimes
  • White Collar Crime

Search

Criminal Defense Court Process

FREE E-BOOK

Learn all about the legal process and your legal rights.

Get Your Free Copy Now

Board Certified, Criminal Law – Texas Board of Legal Specialization (2009-2021), AV Rated by Martindale Hubbell (2015), and listed as a Best Lawyer in America (2015-2022)

Neal quickly won my case!!
P.E.
5-star review image
He doesn't give up, no matter what you're up against
M.F.
5-star review image
They were very responsive and their actions saved me
A.E.
5-star review image

    Contact Our Law Firm




    We respect your privacy. The use of this form does not establish an attorney-client relationship.

    Address
    Neal Davis Law Firm
    The Heights Boulevard Law Building
    1545 Heights Blvd., Suite 700
    Houston, TX 77008

    Map

    Call 24/7
    (713) 227-4444

    Office Hours
    Monday - Saturday
    8:00 AM to 6:00 PM

    Sunday: Closed


    Experienced Criminal Defense Law Firm in Texas

    While based in Houston, our law firm provides knowledgeable representation and comprehensive legal services for individuals throughout Texas, including:


    Location

    Harris County:

    Houston, Pasadena, Baytown

    Montgomery County:

    Conroe, The WoodlandsWillis, Pinehurst

    Fort Bend County:

    Sugar Land, Richmond, Needville, Cinco Ranch


    Your Houston Criminal Defense Lawyer: Neal Davis


    A principle of the American criminal justice system is that all defendants are "innocent until proven guilty." Houston criminal defense attorney Neal Davis and his skilled legal team represent individuals accused of committing crimes. For over 20 years, Neal Davis has successfully defended clients in Texas and federal courts in all types of criminal matters at all phases, from state misdemeanors to complex federal matters. Often, he has favorably resolved criminal cases quickly and quietly, without the need for trial.


    The Neal Davis Law Firm defends the rights of individuals charged with all types of state crimes, including drug offenses , child sex crimes, online solicitation of a minor , child pornography, DWI and intoxication manslaughter, fraud and theft, assault and family violence, and murder and homicide, as well as all types of federal crimes.


    Board Certified, Criminal Law – Texas Board of Legal Specialization. Serving all of counties and federal courts across Texas, including Harris County (Houston), Montgomery County (Conroe), Galveston County and Fort Bend County (Richmond). Enjuris Texas personal injury guide

    © 2023 Neal Davis Law Firm, PLLC. All rights reserved. Law Firm Online Marketing by SEO Advantage, Inc.


    Legal Information

    The information and materials on this website are provided for general informational purposes only, and are not intended to be legal advice. We attempt to provide quality information, but the law changes frequently, and varies from place to place. The information and materials provided are general in nature, and may not apply to a specific factual or legal circumstance. An attorney and client relationship should not be implied. Nothing on this website is intended to substitute for the advice of an attorney; therefore, if you require legal advice, please consult with a competent attorney licensed to practice in your jurisdiction. Every case is different and individual results may vary depending on the facts of a case.