The Heights Boulevard Law Building 1545 Heights Blvd., Ste 700 Houston, TX 77008

Neal Davis: How Salinas Changed the Law of Self Incrimination



Source: National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers™
Author: Neal Davis and Dick DeGuerin
Date: January-February 2014
Photo Credit: National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers

View Original Article

Silence Is No Longer Golden: How Lawyers Must Now Advise Suspects in Light of Salinas v. Texas

Almost 70 years ago, Justice Robert Jackson made the following observation in Watts v. Indiana: “[A]ny lawyer worth his salt will tell the suspect in no uncertain terms to make no statement to police under any circumstances.” But after the Supreme Court’s recent decision in Salinas v. Texas, Justice Jackson’s once-stalwart advice could be tantamount to malpractice if police question a suspect in a noncustodial context. Silence is no longer golden.

Under the Supreme Court’s Alice in Wonderland approach to the Self-Incrimination Clause, witnesses cannot exercise their right to remain silent in a noncustodial context unless they speak up. In a 5-4 decision, Salinas held that a witness, whom police subject to noncustodial questioning without giving the Miranda warning, cannot rely on the Fifth Amendment unless he expressly invokes it. That is, if a witness

TX Personal Injury Law


5-star review image
Muy satisfechos con su trabajo
Dismissal of two online charges

" Estamos muy satisfechos con su representacion en el caso de nuestro sobrino. Siempre obtuvimos respuestas a todas nuestras preguntas, y acceso a ustedes sin ningun problema. El caso se resolvio satisfactoriamente y en una forma muy rapida. Gracias!"

Online Solicitation • Conroe • Rating: 5.0/5
5-star review image
Got my life back
Positive outcome in online solicitation case

" Words cant express how grateful i am for having Neil on my side. I was involved in a police sting for online solicitation. When i though my life was over i contacted Neil. He told me he would do everything he could to get me out of my situation. He kept me up to date and answered when i called. In the end my case ended with a no bill and i can finally start living my life again."

Online Solicitation • Houston • Rating: 5.0/5
5-star review image
He doesn't give up, no matter what you're up against
Client's child sex abuse case was dismissed

" This man saved my life from false imprisonment. Neal's belief in 'liberty and justice for all' as laid out in the Constitution of the United States, and especially as that principle relates to constitutional rights regarding the receipt of a fair trial, coupled with his refusal to quit fighting, are attributes of a noble spirit and a man of high character. When I interviewed Neal to defend me against very serious false accusations and criminal charges that followed, his candor about what I was up against and his real interest in my general welfare made choosing him to defend me a 'no brainer.' Hiring Neal after hearing Dick DeGuerin say 'Neal is a real fighter' was the best decision I could have made and this was after interviewing a number of attorneys. He cares about people, truth, and justice; an attorney who will not give up; a man who will defend the rights of anyone accused of a crime with every fiber of his being to ensure fairness and the protection of our legal rights."

Sex Crimes • Houston • Rating: 5.0/5

Read All Reviews

5/5 based on 50 reviews.