Call Now  (713) 227-4444 Email Us Hablamos
Español

Neal Davis Blog

  • About
    • Neal Davis
    • Tyler Brock
    • Andrew Jordan
    • Hiring An Attorney
  • Expertise
    • Criminal Defense
    • Sex Crime Defense
    • Child Pornography
    • Child Solicitation
    • Drug Possession
    • White Collar Crimes
    • Shoplifing/Theft
    • DWI
    • Murder Defense
    • Assault & Family Violence
    • Title IX Defense
  • Results
  • Reviews
  • Press
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • Criminal Defense Guides
    • Scholarships
Home / Criminal Defense / Do Mugshots Unfairly Brand Innocent People As Guilty?

Do Mugshots Unfairly Brand Innocent People As Guilty?

March 7, 2020

Texas mugshots

Americans’ Constitutional right to be considered innocent until proven guilty is being subverted, if not shredded, by online news displays of an accused person’s name and face in a mugshot before their guilt or innocence is ever proven. This tends to paint individuals who may turn out to be wholly innocent as criminals in the court of public opinion.

As reported by nonprofit journalism site The Marshall Project, such online mugshots are a form of a “digital scarlet letter,” in the view of Matt Waite, journalism professor at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln.

“Legally, it’s public record—but legal is not always right,” he said about publishing mugshots.

The accused person may be found innocent, yet his or her name and face still will be branded with the charge or accusation, even years later. That’s because not only is the Internet everywhere, but it can be forever — always displaying the name and face of an accused (yet innocent) person long after their exoneration.

More immediately, in today’s harshly judgmental world of instant connections via social media, an accusation — whether true or false — tends to spark immediate and widespread condemnation. Before an accused person is exonerated at trial, the damage of an unfounded charge or false claim has been done, and may be far from being undone.

As a consequence, innocent persons can quickly and forever be branded with a charge which can hamper their ability to find employment or further their education. An accusation can also shatter their families and, overnight, ruin a person’s reputation and standing in their community.

What’s more, people who wish to get their mugshot erased from online are often extorted by mugshot removal businesses that seek to earn a profit by forcing individuals to pay a steep fee to have their image removed. Many of these companies harass and shame people who have had run-ins with the criminal justice system, even if their charges were ultimately dropped or dismissed.

No more mugshots of charged persons on news sites

Such problems have prompted some news publications to change their policies by no longer publishing photos of persons accused of or charged with crimes. One such publication is the Houston Chronicle.

According to the Marshall Project, Chronicle editors have agreed to cease posting slideshows of persons who have been arrested but who have not been convicted — and who should be presumed innocent under the law.

“Mugshot slideshows whose primary purpose is to generate page views will no longer appear on our websites,” Mark Lorando, a Chronicle managing editor, said to The Marshall Project. “We’re better than that.”

Praise from defense attorneys and law enforcement

The Chronicle’s decision has gained praise from defense attorneys and local law enforcement.

Jason Spencer, Public Affairs Director for the Harris County Sheriff’s Office, thanked the Chronicle on Twitter for “doing the right thing.” He also wrote, “I’m hopeful that other media outlets and law enforcement agencies will follow your lead and rethink the practice of publicly shaming arrested people who haven’t been convicted of a crime.”

It’s also believed that published mugshots of people of color tend to reinforce biases against them.

“People of color already are more likely to be found guilty than their white counterparts,” Johnny Perez, director of U.S. prison programs for the National Religious Campaign Against Torture, told the Marshall Project.

A published mugshot reaffirms such existing biases and also creates biases where none had existed, Perez said. “It creates this situation where you’re criminalizing folks before they’re convicted of any crime.”

Mugshot removal businesses continue extorting

While we commend new and media organizations like the Houston Chronicle for implementing policies that end the harmful practice of publishing mugshot, this is only one part of the problem. The other part is the mugshot removal service industry.

Since mugshots are public record in Texas and throughout the U.S., private companies can digitally “scrape” and gather the images from law enforcement websites, then publish them on their own sites in a matter of hours. These sites defend their actions by saying that their work is constitutionally protected under the First Amendment.

Texas law on mugshots

In addition to a call for media organizations to voluntarily stop publishing mugshots, the Texas legislature has stepped in to try and regulate the mugshot removal industry. In fact, Texas is one of 18 states with laws on the books designed to restrict Internet mugshot removal business practices.

In September 2013, lawmakers amended the Texas Business & Commerce Code (SB 1289) by prohibiting businesses from publishing criminal record information (including mugshots) if the business has received an order of nondisclosure or notice of expunction. Should the business fail to remove the information after receiving either of these documents, they will be forced to pay up to $500 per day to the person whose information is published, as well as pay for the person’s attorney fees.

Unfortunately, this law only applies to people who are able to get a nondisclosure or expunction order. Mugshots are a public record in Texas, so individuals who are accused of a crime or charged may still have their information and image published at large.

On top of that, this law and others across the country have been largely ineffective in stopping the predatory mugshot removal industry, according to PEW research.

How a criminal defense lawyer can help

Of course, also important in regaining a good name after a criminal charge or accusation is engaging an experienced criminal defense lawyer who can fight to protect your legal rights by applying a strong legal defense.

If you were charged with a crime in Houston, Harris County, Fort Bend County or Montgomery County and need such a defense, contact the Neal Davis Law Firm for a legal review of your case.

Related Resources

  • What is a Deadly Weapon in an Aggravated Assault Charge in Texas?
    What is a Deadly Weapon in an Aggravated Assault Charge in…
  • Neal Davis Scholarship Winner: Largest Challenges to the Criminal Justice System
    Neal Davis Scholarship Winner: Largest Challenges to the…
  • “Rick and Morty” Case Shows How Long Legal Matters Can Proceed
    “Rick and Morty” Case Shows How Long Legal Matters Can…

Learn More About Criminal Defense


Overview of Criminal Defense
Questions to Ask Your Attorney
White Collar Crime
Crime Classifications
Common Criminal Defense Questions
Have You Been Arrested
Death Penalty Law
Criminal Defense Legal Terms
Rights of the Defendant
Employment after Incarceration

5-star review image
Falsely Accused
Criminal Defense  |  Houston
Client was accused of murder and needed strong criminal defense representation. The firm battled not only the prosecution but a barrage of unfavorable media attention. In the end, case resulted in dismissal and justice for our client
2016-06-09
"When I was falsely Accused of Murder and covicted by the media Neal Davis Law Firm was their. ..."
C.B, Verified Customer
5-star review image
He handled my assault case
Assault  |  Houston
Assault case was dismissed
2014-01-02
"He's the best lawyer in Houston. [...] Thank you, Mr. Davis. "
I.A., Verified Customer
5-star review image
He focused on listening and helping, not just explaining his fees
Sex Crimes  |  Houston
Client needed representation for a child sex abuse case that was complex and needed an attorney who understood the full extent of the law.
2015-10-29
"Neal represented our son and the case against him was dismissed, while other attorneys we consulted primarily focused ..."
Father of Juvenile Client I.Z., Verified Customer

Categories

  • Child Pornography & Online Solicitation
  • Community
  • Criminal Defense
  • Drug Crimes
  • Federal Crimes
  • Firm News
  • Intoxication Offenses
  • Sex Crimes
  • Violent Crimes
  • White Collar Crime

Search

Criminal Defense Court Process

FREE E-BOOK

Learn all about the legal process and your legal rights.

Get Your Free Copy Now

Board Certified, Criminal Law – Texas Board of Legal Specialization (2009-2021), AV Rated by Martindale Hubbell (2015), and listed as a Best Lawyer in America (2015-2022)

He doesn't give up, no matter what you're up against
M.F.
5-star review image
Got my life back
K.W.
5-star review image
Muy satisfechos con su trabajo
Tia de J.C.
5-star review image

Read All Reviews

    Contact Our Law Firm




    We respect your privacy. The use of this form does not establish an attorney-client relationship.

    Address
    Neal Davis Law Firm
    The Heights Boulevard Law Building
    1545 Heights Blvd., Suite 700
    Houston, TX 77008

    Map

    Call 24/7
    (713) 227-4444

    Office Hours
    Monday - Saturday
    8:00 AM to 6:00 PM

    Sunday: Closed


    Experienced Criminal Defense Law Firm in Texas

    While based in Houston, our law firm provides knowledgeable representation and comprehensive legal services for individuals throughout Texas, including:


    Location

    Harris County:

    Houston, Pasadena, Baytown

    Montgomery County:

    Conroe, The WoodlandsWillis, Pinehurst

    Fort Bend County:

    Sugar Land, Richmond, Needville, Cinco Ranch


    Your Houston Criminal Defense Lawyer: Neal Davis


    A principle of the American criminal justice system is that all defendants are "innocent until proven guilty." Houston criminal defense attorney Neal Davis and his skilled legal team represent individuals accused of committing crimes. For over 20 years, Neal Davis has successfully defended clients in Texas and federal courts in all types of criminal matters at all phases, from state misdemeanors to complex federal matters. Often, he has favorably resolved criminal cases quickly and quietly, without the need for trial.


    The Neal Davis Law Firm defends the rights of individuals charged with all types of state crimes, including drug offenses , child sex crimes, online solicitation of a minor , child pornography, DWI and intoxication manslaughter, fraud and theft, assault and family violence, and murder and homicide, as well as all types of federal crimes.


    Board Certified, Criminal Law – Texas Board of Legal Specialization. Serving all of counties and federal courts across Texas, including Harris County (Houston), Montgomery County (Conroe), Galveston County and Fort Bend County (Richmond). Enjuris Texas personal injury guide

    © 2023 Neal Davis Law Firm, PLLC. All rights reserved. Law Firm Online Marketing by SEO Advantage, Inc.


    Legal Information

    The information and materials on this website are provided for general informational purposes only, and are not intended to be legal advice. We attempt to provide quality information, but the law changes frequently, and varies from place to place. The information and materials provided are general in nature, and may not apply to a specific factual or legal circumstance. An attorney and client relationship should not be implied. Nothing on this website is intended to substitute for the advice of an attorney; therefore, if you require legal advice, please consult with a competent attorney licensed to practice in your jurisdiction. Every case is different and individual results may vary depending on the facts of a case.