The Heights Boulevard Law Building 1545 Heights Blvd., Ste 700 Houston, TX 77008

The Right to Remain Silent

Source: The New York Times
Author: The Editorial Board
Date: April 20, 2013
Photo Credit: The New York Times

View Original Article

Under the Constitution's Fifth Amendment, no one can be compelled to be a witness against himself in a criminal case. The prosecution cannot use a defendant's decision not to testify in court as evidence of guilt. Nor, as a result of the landmark Miranda case, can it use as evidence of guilt a suspect's decision to remain silent after being arrested.

Last week, the Supreme Court heard oral argument in Salinas v. Texas about whether the right to silence long applied to trials and police interrogations after arrests should now be extended to suspects before they are arrested and given Miranda warnings. The justices should say yes.

Before Genovevo Salinas was charged with murder in Texas, he voluntarily went with police officers for questioning. He answered questions for an hour, but he fell silent rather than answer a key question: whether shotgun shells found at the crime scene would match a shotgun found at his home.

At his trial, the prosecutor called Mr. Salinas's refusal to answer "a very important piece of evidence." Mr. Salinas was convicted of murder in a county court. The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals upheld the conviction, saying the prosecutor's damaging remark was acceptable. The police had not required Mr. Salinas to talk, the court said, so the Fifth Amendment's protection against forced self-incrimination was "irrelevant."

But what that means is that if a suspect does not answer every question from the police during an interrogation before he is arrested, the prosecution can use that silence against him in court. "That is such a radical position, that silence is an admission of guilt," Justice Sonia Sotomayor said during oral argument.

That position gives police officers too much leverage to coerce or cajole a suspect into answering their questions — to compel incriminating testimony in direct contradiction of the Fifth Amendment — or, just as bad, into making a false confession when he is innocent.

There is disagreement among lower courts about this vital issue, some agreeing with Justice Sotomayor, some not. Mr. Salinas's lawyer said the disagreement was intractable and must be resolved by the Supreme Court. So it should — in favor of the idea that a prosecutor may not use a suspect's silence during an interrogation before his arrest as evidence of guilt.

TX Personal Injury Law

5-star review image
He focused on listening and helping, not just explaining his fees
Client needed representation for a child sex abuse case that was complex and needed an attorney who understood the full extent of the law.

" Neal represented our son and the case against him was dismissed, while other attorneys we consulted primarily focused on explaining their fees and pushed us to settle. Neal took time to understand our needs and truly appreciate our values and to convey to the Court, the District Attorney and the Judge the true essence of the case details and the circumstances of how our son was himself victimized, versus treating us as another case. He saw the case through to the utmost extent of the law, so our son, who is an honor student, was completely exonerated, and he made sure that support and professional help were in place during the experience. He declined the court's offer of a 2-year probation and pushed harder with the D.A. even though we had already paid him his fees. Most attorneys would have simply walked away at that point; however, Neal wasn't satisfied with the results and had the case reset since he knew it was not a fair result for my son. In the end, the case was dismissed. "

Sex Crimes • Houston • Rating: 5.0/5
5-star review image
Muy satisfechos con su trabajo
Dismissal of two online charges

" Estamos muy satisfechos con su representacion en el caso de nuestro sobrino. Siempre obtuvimos respuestas a todas nuestras preguntas, y acceso a ustedes sin ningun problema. El caso se resolvio satisfactoriamente y en una forma muy rapida. Gracias!"

Online Solicitation • Conroe • Rating: 5.0/5
5-star review image
Got my life back
Positive outcome in online solicitation case

" Words cant express how grateful i am for having Neil on my side. I was involved in a police sting for online solicitation. When i though my life was over i contacted Neil. He told me he would do everything he could to get me out of my situation. He kept me up to date and answered when i called. In the end my case ended with a no bill and i can finally start living my life again."

Online Solicitation • Houston • Rating: 5.0/5

Read All Reviews

5/5 based on 50 reviews.